December 2019: Weaker Chinese jewellery demand is not offset by growth elsewhere, despite the sustained low platinum price. Net Chinese jewellery demand is over 800 koz lower than it was five years ago and is still trending downwards but at a slower rate. Absent significant growth in other regions, jewellery demand remains the weakest element of the investment case for platinum, despite record price discounts to gold and to palladium. Total jewellery demand will remain largely dependent on a recovery in jewellery fabrication in China.
WPIC research is free of charge. It can continue to be consumed by asset managers under MiFID II
November 2019: Platinum recycle supply growth is steady, largely unresponsive to price and unable to compensate for lower mine supply in 2020. Historically, platinum recycle supply has grown based on past vehicle platinum loadings, the scrappage profiles of vehicles and, counterintuitively, rising jewellery sales in China as platinum’s largest jewellery market was established. We illustrate the nature of automotive recycle supply through palladium where its massive price increase has left its expected recycle supply largely unchanged.
October 2019: Weakness in auto sales are not a strong reason to expect a PGM price pull back. Historically, tightened emissions levels rather than increased vehicle sales caused strong PGM demand growth. This trend has been evident in China this year. In addition, we consider if meaningful platinum demand growth will come from substitution in several low-temperature applications in gasoline vehicles and in palladium-containing diesel autocatalysts.
September 2019: Platinum ETF holdings are up 38% and its price is up 20% yet many commentators believe platinum’s fundamentals are still poor. Large macro funds that were slow to participate in the gold rally have used platinum futures as a proxy for gold and as an alternative to negative yield assets. We expect further growth in investment demand for the remainder of this year as investors continue to factor platinum’s relatively low price ($577/oz below gold and $723/oz below palladium) and improving supply-demand outlook (surplus down to 345 koz in 2019f from 675 koz in 2018).
August 2019: Above Ground Stocks (AGS) increase insight when considering platinum as an investment asset. Above Ground Stocks are a natural part of the physical metal market and have not proved an impediment to higher prices for palladium and nor should they for platinum. Platinum ETF buying of 755 koz in 2019 has tightened the physical market, making holders of unpublished AGS less likely to sell. We believe platinum’s current demand growth potential is a more likely driver of the platinum price now.
July 2019: Automaker strategies to reduce multi-billion Euro CO2 fines increasingly include achieving higher diesel sales. The 2009 EU legislation to reduce CO2 takes effect in 2021. From September 2019 all new diesel cars sold will be Euro 6d TEMP, or RDE, compliant and will finally be ‘clean’ (in NOx terms). This makes it easier for automakers to promote diesel sales including mild hybrid and plug-in hybrid diesel models and is positive for platinum demand.
June 2019: Industrial demand has grown at twice the rate of global growth in the last 5 years and is now the largest portion of net platinum demand. This recent growth, above its long run correlation with global GDP, has partly offset easing Chinese jewellery and European autocatalyst demand. Industrial demand growth is driven by global economic growth and advances in technology but can exhibit short term changes unrelated to macro trends. Steady industrial demand growth, now and in future, underpins platinum.
April 2019: Bar and coin and ETF demand are important to the platinum investment case. Given the low current platinum price and the spectacular 2019 year-to-date growth in ETF holdings, it is worth looking at the relative roles of owned and exchanged traded investment in physical platinum.
March 2019: The overall PGM picture looks strong, despite the platinum surplus. Palladium’s 2019 market deficit is estimated to approach 1 moz, assuming zero investment demand. This more than exceeds the combined surpluses estimated for platinum and rhodium. As the metals are to a significant extent fungible, a large market imbalance in one metal should result in a rebalancing among the PGMs, as we discuss in this report.
February 2019: Platinum provides some diversification benefit for portfolios. Recent market volatility reminds us of the importance of portfolio diversification. Adding a risky asset to an existing portfolio reduces overall portfolio volatility when the new asset has a correlation <1.0 with the existing portfolio. Our note explores platinum’s diversification dynamics and qualities.
January 2019: Sustained palladium futures curve backwardation has ramifications for platinum. When futures curves change shape, they can impart valuable market information. The palladium futures curve has been in backwardation for over a year, a sign of a shortage in the metal. This is another indicator arguing for substitution of palladium by platinum in automotive applications, in our view.
December 2018: FCVs represent material long-term platinum demand. We investigate the potential impact of fuel cell electric vehicles on platinum demand, building a baseline forecast anchored on announced fuel cell vehicle and infrastructure plans in Japan, China, California and elsewhere. We find it generates material demand in the coming years.
November 2018: Upcoming China emissions regulations look likely to have a meaningful impact on PGMs demand. We highlight the likely impact of the upcoming China 6 emissions standards on platinum and platinum group metals (PGM) demand. The combination of tightening emissions standards and continued auto production growth means that China’s appetite for these metals has significant room to grow.
October 2018: The palladium premium is a potential platinum opportunity. We highlight the sustained palladium price premium to platinum and the potential effect on platinum demand. Historical substitution trends among platinum, palladium and rhodium in automotive catalysts mean that a sustained significant price premium of palladium over platinum looks unlikely.
September 2018 (II): ETFs are an essential component of platinum demand. We highlight that Platinum ETFs, being physically backed, form an essential part of the annual platinum demand as vaulted allocated bars backing them are purchased in the spot market.
September 2018 (I): Selective Catalytic Reduction systems do use platinum. We explain that Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR) systems on diesel cars do not remove the need for platinum. Achieving low on-road NOx emissions should see higher platinum loadings on LNT and SCR emissions control systems.
June 2018: The palladium price is important for platinum investors. We outline how high demand and consecutive deficits increase risks to automakers of insufficient palladium and are a potential driver of substitution by platinum in gasoline cars.
May 2018: We look at fuel cell electric vehicle (FCEV) adoption, a potential driver of platinum demand. The similarity of fuel cell power growth to past growth in wind and solar power has not been widely recognised.
April 2018: Platinum’s attraction to gold investors. We highlight platinum’s precious metal attributes that could appeal to gold investors.
March 2018: A new platinum ETF in the US adds a vehicle to invest in platinum. We address why the launch of a new ETF in the U.S. could increase investor interest and investment demand for platinum.
February 2018: Platinum loadings in diesel cars could well rise. We discuss automakers’ potential emissions strategies and the desire to avoid any risk of exceeding legal limits in real world driving conditions.
January 2018: Diesel cars may still be needed to meet carbon dioxide targets. We explore whether new car CO2 will continue to rise, and whether diesel will continue to be a negative for platinum sentiment.
December 2017: Sibanye-Stillwater’s purchase of Lonmin could be significant for the platinum market. We explore whether Sibanye-Stillwater’s proposed acquisition of Lonmin is meaningful to the platinum market.
November 2017: China auto sales growth augurs well for platinum demand. We discuss the upside potential from China auto demand.
October 2017: Over specific periods, platinum has a positive correlation with gold. We discuss what the positive correlation with gold means.
September 2017: Independent testing could help diesel cars. We discuss how independent testing could impact European diesel passenger market share.
August 2017: China jewellery demand is has been in a down cycle. We address why the impact of declining China jewellery demand could be offset by upside potential in India.
July 2017: What do electric vehicle mean for the platinum market? We explore why the market may be overestimating the potential impact on platinum demand from electric vehicles.
June 2017: Declining European diesel may be overestimated. We address the potential impact on platinum demand from the declining European diesel market share, and reasons why the market may be overestimating the negatives.